I’m not always happy with the results on American Idol. But I respect democracy.
Today, I’m more than unhappy… I’m completely befuddled and disappointed with my fellow Idol watchers/voters.
There were only 3 girls in the Top 9 ( that’s like 30 percent…fyi) and that was before last nights elimination. Of the 3 girls ramaining, only one of them (in my humble opinion) was worthy and had an honest SHOT at the title. That would be Pia. The other two, have been in the bottom before, and have narrowly escaped elimination… but have had some recent success.
Let me get right to it… shocker of the season (becuase the save is no longer in place) Pia went home.
Even more shocking than the Casey elimination and save. Yes, I said it. Because Pia had no second chance, and no fair warning. The wrong girl went home tonight, and it’s certainly a kick in the teeth for such a talented singer to leave before her time.
Now, I would argue that both Hayley and Lauren will benefit from this ousting. They will pick up many of the voters Pia lost… and will stay long PAST their due.
What did you think? Am I off base, was it really Pia’s time?